I was recently asked why there are songs tagged as Waltz in the music4dance catalog that are in 4/4 time. This seems almost like the dance version of an oxymoron. In my brief description of the Waltz on the website I start with “Waltzes are dances that are danced to music in 3/4 time…”
To be honest, the main reason that there are “Waltzes” that aren’t Waltzes in the catalog is that I pull from lots of different sources and even with something this fundamental there are different schools of thought. I intentionally error towards the inclusive in these decisions since I think that dance should be as inclusive as possible.
A substantial number of these songs come from sources that cater to people looking for wedding dances. But there are definitely “Waltzes” in 4/4 coming from other sources as well, I’ve certainly seen some exhibition Waltzes performed to music that has almost no discernable beat, much less a strong 3/4.
I’m not sure where I picked up this term, but these songs are what I have been calling “Fake” waltzes. If anyone has a better term for this, I would love to hear it.
In any case, a “Fake” waltz is generally a song that is in 4/4 but has a strong downbeat and very weak rhythm otherwise, so that one can dance three steps to a measure without being too distracted by the actual rhythm of the song. You can find all of the songs that I’ve tagged as “Fake” waltzes by following these steps:
- Go to the Advanced search page
- Under “Dance styles”, choose Waltz
- Under “Include tags” click on the blue drum (tempo tags)
- Choose “Fake” and click Include
- Click the Search button
Or just click here for the pre-built search.
You can use the same process, but replace step (4) with choosing “4/4” and you can find all the songs that are cataloged as both waltz and 4/4.
The more interesting variations are to use the same process to find all waltzes that are not tagged “Fake” and not tagged “4/4”. You can do this by using “Exclude Tags” in step 3 above. And you can do one or more tags at the same time.
And while I’m on the subject of unusual waltzes, there is another variation on this theme. It is a song with an extremely slow primary tempo where you can fit a very fast waltz half basic (three steps) on each beat. I’ve been labeling these as “triple-time” and the list can be found here. Although that’s an exaggeration, there is only one song on that list as of this writing – Louis Armstrong’s “What a Wonderful Life”. Perhaps I’ll find more by the time you read this.
I’m looking into ways to make the fact that a waltz is “Fake” more obvious. Currently, it’s a tag on the dance which can only be seen when you click on the dance tag in a song list or by going to the song details page.
In the meantime, if you have a strong objection to songs in 4/4 being labeled as Waltz, you’re welcome to sign up and start voting them down or tagging them as “Fake.”
Even more than usual, I’m interested in how other people view this, so please feel free to comment on this post or send feedback directly to me.